- May 03, 2025
- 8 min read
Handling Cut Day with Class
Cut day is one of the most challenging moments for coaches at any level, from middle school to college. It’s a time when tough decisions are made, dreams are deferred, and emotions run high. Handling these moments with empathy, transparency, and professionalism not only preserves team morale but also builds a culture of respect and growth. This article explores strategies for navigating cut day with class, ensuring athletes leave the process with dignity and coaches maintain their integrity.
Let’s dive into how coaches can approach cut day thoughtfully and constructively.
Preparation: Setting the Stage for Respectful Cuts
The foundation for a respectful cut day is laid long before the announcements are made. Clear communication throughout the tryout process is essential. Coaches should establish transparent criteria for selection, such as skill level, work ethic, or team fit, and share these with athletes early on. This clarity helps athletes understand the expectations and reduces the shock of being cut. Additionally, fostering an environment of open dialogue during tryouts encourages athletes to ask questions and seek feedback, making the eventual decision feel less abrupt.
A cut doesn’t define an athlete’s worth; how we deliver it shapes their perspective.
Sarah Mitchell
High School Volleyball Coach
Delivery: Communicating with Empathy and Clarity
When it’s time to deliver the news, prioritize one-on-one conversations whenever possible. Group announcements can feel impersonal and humiliating, especially for younger athletes. In these private meetings, be honest but compassionate. Explain the decision in the context of the established criteria, and highlight the athlete’s strengths alongside areas for improvement. Offering constructive feedback shows respect for their effort and provides a path forward. Avoid vague or overly general explanations, as these can leave athletes feeling confused or dismissed.
Follow-Up: Supporting Athletes Post-Cut
The conversation doesn’t end when an athlete is cut. Providing resources or next steps can soften the blow and demonstrate your commitment to their development. For example, suggest alternative programs, such as junior varsity teams, recreational leagues, or skill-building clinics. If appropriate, connect them with other coaches or mentors who can help them continue their journey. Following up a few days later with a brief check-in—whether through a quick email or a handshake at school—reinforces that you value them as individuals, not just as potential team members.
Practical Tips for Handling Cut Day
- Communicate tryout criteria clearly from the start.
- Conduct cuts privately to respect athletes’ dignity.
- Provide specific, constructive feedback during cut conversations.
- Offer alternative opportunities or resources for growth.
- Follow up to show continued support and care.
Handling cut day with class is about more than just making roster decisions—it’s about fostering resilience, maintaining trust, and upholding the values of your program. By preparing thoughtfully, communicating with empathy, and supporting athletes after the fact, coaches can turn a difficult moment into an opportunity for growth, both for the athletes and the team culture as a whole.
You may also like
Dirty little secrets about the business industry
July 21, 2021
